Trump’s court battle with the Associated Press. Credit: noamgalai, Shutterstock
A federal appeals court on Friday, June 6, handed Donald Trump a legal win in his battle with the Associated Press (AP), ruling that the White House can legally ban the AP from accessing presidential spaces like the Oval Office, Mar-a-Lago, and Air Force One.
Why is the AP banned? Because of a disagreement over how to name a body of water. AP reportedly refused to rename the Gulf of Mexico the “Gulf of America,” as Trump had ordered. The wire agency continued to use its standard stylebook, acknowledging Trump’s preference but sticking with the internationally recognised name.
In response, Trump’s team revoked AP’s traditional press pool access in February – a key role that allows select reporters into high-security and tight-space locations to represent the wider press corps.
Yesterday, Trump posted on Truth Social, “Big WIN over AP today. They refused to state the facts or the Truth on the GULF OF AMERICA. FAKE NEWS!!!”
Court backs Trump’s power over AP access
The U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington ruled 2–1 in favour of Trump, granting a stay on an earlier lower court decision that required the White House to reinstate AP’s access.
Judges Gregory Katsas and Neomi Rao – both Trump appointees in his first term – agreed the president had broad discretion in choosing which journalists are allowed into restricted government spaces.
The ruling reinforces the idea that spaces like the Oval Office are not public forums like parks or pavements and therefore aren’t protected by the same free speech standards.
But dissenting Judge Cornelia Pillard, appointed by Barack Obama, warned of serious press freedom risks: “It’s not hard to see future Republican White Houses limiting the press to Fox News, and Democrats to MSNBC.” She called it “viewpoint discrimination,” arguing that excluding critical outlets could chill free expression across the media landscape.
Trump vs. the media: a long-running feud
This is far from Trump’s first clash with the press – he previously sued ABC News and had a run-in with a CNN reporter. While the AP has covered presidents for nearly two centuries, the Trump White House has shifted access to favour conservative and pro-Trump media outlets.
Press secretary Karoline Leavitt celebrated the latest ruling, posting on X:
“VICTORY! More media access beyond the failing legacy media. And by the way, @AP, it’s still the Gulf of America.”
Meanwhile, the AP says it’s reviewing its legal options, stating: “We are disappointed in the court’s decision.”
Is the Oval Office public or private?
The court ruling has reignited fierce debate over free speech. If presidents can pick and choose who covers them, some worry it sets a dangerous precedent where only biased media survive. Others argue that no journalist has a guaranteed right to presidential briefings, especially if their work “undermines” the administration.
View all news from the USA.
