Claims of illegal immigrants eventually benefiting the American economy have been debunked by studies.
Forty-one Democrat mayors and county officials wrote a letter to President Joe Biden asking his administration to grant parole and work permits for millions of illegal immigrants residing in the United States.
They noted that roughly 11.3 million American citizens today share a home with an undocumented individual. As such, this issue is critical in certain “key electoral states” like Nevada, Arizona, Wisconsin, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Georgia, and North Carolina, they wrote.
Democrats asked the Department of Homeland Security to “leverage its authority” to grant parole for both long-term and recent illegal immigrants, thus qualifying them for work authorization. Allowing illegal immigrants to legally work in the country would result in higher wages, shield them from workplace exploitation, and enable them to contribute to the economy, they said.
Fiscal Impact
Claims of illegal immigrants boosting the U.S. economy have been countered by several studies. A March 2023 analysis by the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) found that the United States bears a fiscal burden of $150.7 billion annually due to illegal immigration.
“Tax payments by illegal aliens cover only around a sixth of the costs they create at all levels in this country,” the analysis said. “Many illegal aliens actually receive a net cash profit through refundable tax credit programs.” Moreover, numerous illegal immigrants work in the underground economy and thus avoid paying income taxes at all, FAIR noted.
While the total revenue paid by illegal aliens was just under $32 billion, their gross negative economic impact was roughly six times at $182 billion. Each illegal alien or U.S.-born child of such people costs Americans $8,776 annually.
In their letter, the Democrats suggested that the Biden administration could kick start the parole and work permit authorization for illegal immigrants by expanding the parole currently granted to spouses and parents of U.S. military service members. The expansion can provide parole to 1.2 million undocumented spouses of U.S. citizens in the country, they wrote.
In addition, the administration can focus on a work permit program for undocumented illegal immigrants who have been living in the United States for 10 or more years, the letter said. They also suggested instituting a parole program for “Dreamers” who are too young and ineligible for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program.
“It is time to extend work permits to bring millions out of the shadows. On behalf of our new residents and long-term immigrants, we urge you to use this authority to everyone’s shared benefit,” the letter said.
Massive Illegal Immigrant Influx
The Democrat push for granting work permits to illegal immigrants comes as there has been a massive influx of such individuals under the Biden administration.
In January 2021, the first month in office, President Joe Biden stopped the border wall construction, halted the Remain in Mexico program, repurposed ICE priorities, and reversed the ban on travel from terror-prone countries.
However, the administration insists it is working towards controlling the border crisis. President Biden has “called on Congress to fix our broken immigration system” from the first day in his office, White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said in a May 20 statement.
“Earlier this year, his Administration reached a bipartisan agreement on the toughest and fairest set of reforms in decades … This bipartisan border legislation would deliver the significant policy changes, resources, and personnel needed to secure our border and make our country safer.”
Republicans blocked the bill a few months back, with many calling the provisions insufficient to secure the border. GOP lawmakers pointed out that the bill does not include restoring former President Donald Trump’s Remain in Mexico policy, which many Republicans consider a must-have in any border security legislation.
The Border Act of 2024 includes a provision that allows for shutting down the border if the average daily illegal immigrants encountered by officials comes to more than 5,000 per day for seven consecutive days.
However, opponents point out that allowing 5,000 illegal aliens into the United States every day would make the immigrant crisis facing the country even worse.
After the bill was rejected by the Senate, President Biden blamed Republicans for not caring about “securing the border or fixing America’s broken immigration system.” He accused GOP lawmakers of putting partisan politics above national security.
While the initial vote in February was backed by a few Republicans, no lawmaker from the party supported the measure this time around. Many GOP members accused the bill of being a Democrat political ploy that would end up worsening the border situation.
“The fact of the matter is that President Trump had the authority to secure the border. He did. Biden used that exact same authority to open it back up,” Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) told The Epoch Times.
