Tuesday, February 7, 2023
HomeOpinionOpinion | Is Use of the Demise Penalty Ever Ethical?

Opinion | Is Use of the Demise Penalty Ever Ethical?

Nancy Keenan-Wealthy
Poughkeepsie, N.Y.

To the Editor:

In endorsing capital punishment for the “worst of the worst criminals,” and in suggesting that “retributive justice” is a method of acknowledging the total humanity and free will of an individual convicted of aggravated homicide, Robert Blecker fails to grasp that a vital a part of Nikolas Cruz’s humanity was destroyed earlier than he was born.

Mr. Cruz suffers from fetal alcohol spectrum dysfunction, which has profound penalties on mind improvement, impulse management, cognitive capability and habits.

Mr. Blecker’s methodology requires him to place himself within the sneakers of the victims, however he fails in his effort at making a framework for true sentencing justice as a result of he seems incapable of placing himself within the sneakers of the brain-damaged Mr. Cruz, whose full humanity was damaged in a means that made his will a lot lower than free.

Mercy is a part of the human situation and is the last word acknowledgment of human dignity.

Michael Iaria
Bainbridge Island, Wash.
The author is a prison protection lawyer who handles capital circumstances and has represented purchasers with fetal alcohol spectrum dysfunction.

To the Editor:

The headline asks, “If Not the Parkland Shooter, Who Is the Demise Penalty For?” How about … no one?

The loss of life penalty has been convincingly proven to not be a deterrent to future criminals, nor does it do something to deliver a killer’s victims again to life. All it does is precise revenge whereas typically ensuing within the execution of harmless folks.

It’s comprehensible {that a} sufferer’s household could be so overcome by emotion that it favors the loss of life penalty, however the banning of this barbaric follow is lengthy overdue.

Jeff Burger
Ridgewood, N.J.

To the Editor:

Prof. Robert Blecker appears as incapable of feeling pity for Nikolas Cruz as Mr. Cruz was of feeling pity for his victims. Simply as I can not think about the phobia and ache these victims felt within the lengthy moments earlier than their deaths, I can not think about the horror of Mr. Cruz’s life. On no account does that horrific childhood justify his crimes. But it surely does make me really feel sorrow for him alongside together with his victims.

Source link



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular