Spain’s train trouble: Delays, breakdowns, and trackside mayhem spark commuter fury

It’s no secret that delays, breakdowns, and overcrowding have left many Spanish commuters fuming. But as frustrations boil over, one question lingers: are the trains in Spain still among Europe’s best? The surprising answer is yes.

“It’s chaos some days,” says Jorge Lopez Montoro, a technician waiting for his Chamartin-bound train, which is nearly twenty minutes late in Madrid. “But when you compare it to other countries, we’ve still got it pretty good. At least tickets are affordable, and trains are relatively fast and clean.” It’s a mixed sentiment echoed by commuters across Spain.

A runaway problem

The frustrations of passengers like Mr Lopez Montoro echo across Spain, with X, Instagram and Facebook flooded daily by angry rants about the chaotic state of the railways. October saw over 15,000 passengers stranded at Madrid’s two main stations after a derailed train and a passenger trespassing on the tracks ground services to a halt.

And that’s just the tip of the iceberg. Across the network, delays, overcrowding, copper thefts, and trains breaking down mid-journey have made headlines across Europe. Commuters trapped in tunnels for hours without water or electricity are just one symptom of a system straining under its own success.

Crisis on the tracks

According to experts in Spain, the biggest issue isn’t just the delays but the deteriorating quality of service. The main problem is capacity at stations and poor disruption management. A general lack of information often turns a delay into a social media storm, as passengers grow exasperated.

National operator Renfe is bearing the brunt of the backlash, having recorded its worst-ever year for delays in 2023. Both its high-speed AVE and medium-distance services were plagued by problems, with causes ranging from rising passenger numbers to ongoing infrastructure works.

Too many trains, too little time

Renfe’s monopoly ended in 2021, with competition steaming in from French state operator Ouigo and Italy-backed Iryo. While the rivalry has slashed ticket prices and added more services, it’s also come at a cost. Renfe’s low-cost Avlo trains might be cheap, but compensation for delays has also been cut. Refunds for 30-minute delays? Gone. Now, passengers only get half their money back for delays over an hour, or the full amount for delays beyond 90 minutes. Systematic barriers are also being put in place to prevent passengers from applying for their refunds. If you buy an online ticket, the customer service links send you around in circles and ask you for reference numbers that don’t appear on your ticket. The only way to get the reference number is to go through a lengthy phone call. It’s weaponised bureaucracy from the masters themselves.

Boom or bust?

The result has been a surge in passengers, with Spain’s railways breaking records last year, carrying over 665 million travellers – a 20% jump from 2019. According to experts, these growing pains will soon subside. The end of Renfe’s monopoly has opened a world of possibilities and has created a boom that the industry is currently adapting to.

Projects like the overhaul of Madrid’s Chamartín station aim to double high-speed rail capacity by 2026. But until then, construction chaos is causing even more delays. Barcelona’s Sants station is facing similar issues, and new trains from manufacturer Talgo are adding to the mess. Delivered two years late, some are already breaking down, with Renfe suing Talgo for millions in damages.

The oldest high-speed line between Madrid and Seville is in desperate need of a signalling system upgrade – a costly and time-consuming job. Meanwhile, low-cost operators are expanding into regions like Andalusia, promising more services but also adding pressure to an already strained network.

Will it all come off the rails?

Experts point out that, while Spain’s rail woes make waves, they’re still better than train systems in other similar European countries like France, Italy, or the UK. But they warn that night train connections to neighbouring countries, once thriving, have vanished since the pandemic. Without investment in cross-border services and traveller-friendly policies, Spain risks missing the train boom. But, for now, local passengers are left wondering when- if ever- Spain’s railways will get back on track.

Find more news in English from around Spain.

Read more news in English from around Europe.